CHAPTER 8
1710, 1711. 

WALKER'S EXPEDITION. 
SCHEME OF LA RONDE DENYS,  BOSTON WARNED AGAINST BRITISH DESIGNS,  BOSTON TO BE RUINED,  PLANS OF THE MINISTRY,  CANADA DOOMED,  BRITISH TROOPS AT BOSTON,  THE COLONISTS DENOUNCED,  THE FLEET SAILS FOR QUEBEC,  FOREBODINGS OF THE ADMIRAL,  STORM AND WRECK,  TIMID COMMANDERS,  RETREAT,  JOYFUL NEWS FOR CANADA,  PIOUS EXULTATION,  FANCIFUL STORIES,  WALKER DISGRACED. 

Military aid from Old England to New, promised in one year and actually given in the next, was a fact too novel and surprising to escape the notice either of friends or of foes. 
The latter drew strange conclusions from it.  Two Irish deserters from an English station in Newfoundland appeared at the French post of Placentia full of stories of British and provincial armaments against Canada.  On this, an idea seized the French commandant, Costebelle, and he hastened to make it known to the colonial minister.  It was to the effect that the aim of England was not so much to conquer the French colonies as to reduce her own to submission, especially Massachusetts,—a kind of republic which has never willingly accepted a governor from its king.  In sending ships and soldiers to the "Bastonnais" under pretence of helping them to conquer their French neighbors, Costebelle is sure that England only means to bring them to a dutiful subjection.  "I do not think," he writes on another occasion, "that they are so blind as not to see that they will insensibly be brought under the yoke of the Parliament of Old England; but by the cruelties that the Canadians and Indians exercise in continual incursions upon their lands, I judge that they would rather be delivered from the inhumanity of such neighbors than preserve all the former powers of their little republic. " He thinks, however, that the design of England ought to be strongly represented to the Council at Boston, and that M.  de la Ronde Denys will be a good man to do it, as he speaks English, has lived in Boston, and has many acquaintances there. 

The minister, Ponchartrain, was struck by Costebelle's suggestion, and wrote both to him and to Vaudreuil in high approval of it.  To Vaudreuil he says: "Monsieur de Costebelle has informed me that the chief object of the armament made by the English last year was to establish their sovereignty at Boston and New York, the people of these provinces having always maintained a sort of republic, governed by their council, and having been unwilling to receive absolute governors from the kings of England.  This destination of the armament seems to me probable, and it is much to be wished that the Council at Boston could be informed of the designs of the English court, and shown how important it is for that province to remain in the state of a republic.  The King would even approve our helping it to do so.  If you see any prospect of success, no means should be spared to secure it.  The matter is of the greatest importance, but care is essential to employ persons who have the talents necessary for conducting it, besides great secrecy and prudence, as well as tried probity and fidelity.  This affair demands your best attention, and must be conducted with great care and precaution, in order that no false step may be taken. "

Ponchartrain could not be supposed to know that while under her old charter Massachusetts, called by him and other Frenchmen the government of Boston, had chosen her own governor, New York had always received hers from the court.  What is most curious in this affair is the attitude of Louis XIV. , who abhorred republics, and yet was prepared to bolster up one or more of them beyond the Atlantic,—thinking, no doubt, that they would be too small and remote to be dangerous. 

Costebelle, who had suggested the plan of warning the Council at Boston, proceeded to unfold his scheme for executing it.  This was to send La Ronde Denys to Boston in the spring, under the pretext of treating for an exchange of prisoners, which would give him an opportunity of insinuating to the colonists that the forces which the Queen of England sends to join their own for the conquest of Acadia and Canada have no object whatever but that of ravishing from them the liberties they have kept so firmly and so long, but which would be near ruin if the Queen should become mistress of New France by the fortune of war; and that either they must have sadly fallen from their ancient spirit, or their chiefs have been corrupted by the Court of London, if they do not see that they are using their own weapons for the destruction of their republic. 

La Ronde Denys accordingly received his instructions, which authorized him to negotiate with the "Bastonnais" as with an independent people, and offer them complete exemption from French hostility if they would promise to give no more aid to Old England either in ships or men.  He was told at the same time to approach the subject with great caution, and unless he found willing listeners, to pass off the whole as a pleasantry.  He went to Boston, where he was detained in consequence of preparations then on foot for attacking Canada.  He tried to escape; but his vessel was seized and moored under the guns of the town, and it is needless to say that his mission was a failure. 

The idea of Costebelle, or rather of La Ronde,—for it probably originated with him,—was not without foundation; for though there is no reason to believe that in sending ships and soldiers against the French, England meant to use them against the liberties of her own colonies, there can be no doubt that she thought those liberties excessive and troublesome; and, on the other side, while the people of Massachusetts were still fondly attached to the land of their fathers, and still called it "Home," they were at the same time enamoured of their autonomy, and jealously watchful against any abridgment of it. 

While La Ronde Denys was warning Massachusetts of the danger of helping England to conquer Canada, another Frenchman, in a more prophetic spirit, declared that England would make a grave mistake if she helped her colonies to the same end.  "There is an antipathy," this writer affirms, "between the English of Europe and those of America, who will not endure troops from England even to guard their forts;" and he goes on to say that if the French colonies should fall, those of England would control the continent from Newfoundland to Florida.  "Old England"—such are his words—"will not imagine that these various provinces will then unite, shake off the yoke of the English monarchy, and erect themselves into a democracy. " Forty or fifty years later, several Frenchmen made the same prediction; but at this early day, when the British provinces were so feeble and divided, it is truly a remarkable one. 

The anonymous prophet regards the colonies of England, Massachusetts above all, as a standing menace to those of France; and he proposes a drastic remedy against the danger.  This is a powerful attack on Boston by land and sea, for which he hopes that God will prepare the way.  "When Boston is reduced, we would call together all the chief men of the other towns of New England, who would pay heavy sums to be spared from the flames.  As for Boston, it should be pillaged, its workshops, manufactures, shipyards, all its fine establishments ruined, and its ships sunk. " If these gentle means are used thoroughly, he thinks that New England will cease to be a dangerous rival for some time, especially if "Rhodelene" (Rhode Island) is treated like Boston. 

While the correspondent of the French court was thus consigning New England to destruction, an attack was preparing against Canada less truculent but quite as formidable as that which he urged against Boston.  The French colony was threatened by an armament stronger in proportion to her present means of defence than that which brought her under British rule half a century later.  But here all comparison ceases; for there was no Pitt to direct and inspire, and no Wolfe to lead. 

The letters of Dudley, the proposals of Vetch, the representations of Nicholson, the promptings of Jeremiah Dummer, agent of Massachusetts in England, and the speech made to the Queen by the four Indians who had been the London sensation of the last year, had all helped to draw the attention of the ministry to the New World, and the expediency of driving the French out of it.  Other influences conspired to the same end, or in all likelihood little or nothing would have been done.  England was tiring of the Continental war, the costs of which threatened ruin.  Marlborough was rancorously attacked, and his most stanch supporters the Whigs had given place to the Tories, led by the Lord Treasurer Harley, and the Secretary of State Saint  John, soon afterwards Lord Bolingbroke.  Never was party spirit more bitter; and the new ministry found a congenial ally in the coarse and savage but powerful genius of Swift, who, incensed by real or imagined slights from the late minister, Godolphin, gave all his strength to the winning side. 

The prestige of Marlborough's victories was still immense.  Harley and Saint  John dreaded it as their chief danger, and looked eagerly for some means of counteracting it.  Such means would be supplied by the conquest of New France.  To make America a British continent would be an achievement almost worth Blenheim or Ramillies, and one, too, in which Britain alone would be the gainer; whereas the enemies of Marlborough, with Swift at their head, contended that his greatest triumphs turned more to the profit of Holland or Germany than of England.  Moreover, to send a part of his army across the Atlantic would tend to cripple his movements and diminish his fame. 

Saint  John entered with ardor into the scheme.  Seven veteran regiments, five of which were from the army in Flanders, were ordered to embark.  But in the choice of commanders the judgment of the ministers was not left free; there were influences that they could not disregard.  The famous Sarah, Duchess of Marlborough, lately the favorite of the feeble but wilful queen, had lost her good graces and given place to Mrs.  Masham, one of the women of her bedchamber.  The new favorite had a brother, John Hill, known about the court as Jack Hill, whom Marlborough had pronounced good for nothing, but who had been advanced to the rank of colonel, and then of brigadier, through the influence of Mrs.  Masham; and though his agreeable social qualities were his best recommendation, he was now appointed to command the troops on the Canada expedition.  It is not so clear why the naval command was given to Admiral Sir Hovenden Walker, a man whose incompetence was soon to become notorious. 

Extreme care was taken to hide the destination of the fleet.  Even the Lords of the Admiralty were kept ignorant of it.  Some thought the ships bound for the West Indies; some for the South Sea.  Nicholson was sent to America with orders to the several colonies to make ready men and supplies.  He landed at Boston on the eighth of June.  The people of the town, who were nearly all Whigs, were taken by surprise, expecting no such enterprise on the part of the Tory ministry; and their perplexity was not diminished when they were told that the fleet was at hand, and that they were to supply it forthwith with provisions for ten weeks.  There was no time to lose.  The governors of New York, Connecticut, and Rhode Island were summoned to meet at New London, and Dudley and Nicholson went thither to join them.  Here plans were made for the double attack; for while Walker and Hill were to sail up the Saint  Lawrence against Quebec, Nicholson, as in the former attempt, was to move against Montreal by way of Lake Champlain.  In a few days the arrangements were made, and the governors hastened back to their respective posts. 

When Dudley reached Boston, he saw Nantasket Roads crowded with transports and ships of war, and the pastures of Noddle's Island studded with tents.  The fleet had come on the twenty-fourth, having had what the Admiral calls "by the blessing of God a favorable and extraordinary passage, being but seven weeks and two days between Plymouth and Nantasket. "

The Admiral and the General had been welcomed with all honor.  The provincial Secretary, with two members of the Council, conducted them to town amid salutes from the batteries of Copp's Hill and Fort Hill, and the Boston militia regiment received them under arms; after which they were feasted at the principal tavern, and accompanied in ceremony to the lodgings provided for them.  When the troops were disembarked and the tents pitched, curious townspeople and staring rustics crossed to Noddle's Island, now East Boston, to gaze with wonder on a military pageant the like of which New England had never seen before.  Yet their joy at this unlooked-for succor was dashed with deep distrust and jealousy.  They dreaded these new and formidable friends, with their imperious demeanor and exacting demands.  The British officers, on their part, were no better pleased with the colonists, and one of them, Colonel King, of the artillery, thus gives vent to his feelings: "You'll find in my Journal what Difficultyes we mett with through the Misfortune that the Coloneys were not inform'd of our Coming two Months sooner, and through the Interestedness, ill Nature, and Sowerness of these People, whose Government, Doctrine, and Manners, whose Hypocracy and canting, are insupportable; and no man living but one of Gen'l Hill's good Sense and good Nature could have managed them.  But if such a Man mett with nothing he could depend on, altho' vested with the Queen's Royal Power and Authority, and Supported by a Number of Troops sufficient to reduce by force all the Coloneys, 'tis easy to determine the Respect and Obedience her Majesty may reasonably expect from them. " And he gives it as his conviction that till all the colonies are deprived of their charters and brought under one government, "they will grow more stiff and disobedient every Day. "

It will be seen that some coolness on the part of the Bostonians was not unnatural.  But whatever may have been the popular feeling, the provincial authorities did their full part towards supplying the needs of the new-comers; for Dudley, with his strong Tory leanings, did not share the prevailing jealousy, and the country members of the Assembly were anxious before all things to be delivered from war-parties.  The problem was how to raise the men and furnish the supplies in the least possible time.  The action of the Assembly, far from betraying any slackness, was worthy of a military dictatorship.  All ordinary business was set aside.  Bills of credit for £40,000 were issued to meet the needs of the expedition.  It was ordered that the prices of provisions and other necessaries of the service should stand fixed at the point where they stood before the approach of the fleet was known.  Sheriffs and constables, jointly with the Queen's officers, were ordered to search all the town for provisions and liquors, and if the owners refused to part with them at the prescribed prices, to break open doors and seize them.  Stringent and much-needed Acts were passed against harboring deserters.  Provincial troops, in greater number than the ministry had demanded, were ordered to be raised at once, and quartered upon the citizens, with or without their consent, at the rate of eightpence a day for each man.  Warrants were issued for impressing pilots, and also mechanics and laborers, who, in spite of Puritan scruples, were required to work on Sundays. 

Such measures, if imposed by England, would have roused the most bitter resentment.  Even when ordered by their own representatives, they caused a sullen discontent among the colonists, and greatly increased the popular dislike of their military visitors.  It was certain that when the expedition sailed and the operation of the new enactments ceased, prices would rise; and hence the compulsion to part with goods at low fixed rates was singularly trying to the commercial temper.  It was a busy season, too, with the farmers, and they showed no haste to bring their produce to the camp.  Though many of the principal inhabitants bound themselves by mutual agreement to live on their family stores of salt provisions, in order that the troops might be better supplied with fresh, this failed to soothe the irritation of the British officers, aggravated by frequent desertions, which the colonists favored, and by the impossibility of finding pilots familiar with the Saint  Lawrence.  Some when forced into the service made their escape, to the great indignation of Walker, who wrote to the governor: "Her Majesty will resent such actions in a very signal manner; and when it shall be represented that the people live here as if there were no king in Israel, but every one does what seems right in his own eyes, measures will be taken to put things upon a better foot for the future. " At length, however, every preparation was made, the supplies were all on board, and after a grand review of the troops on the fields of Noddle's Island, the whole force set sail on the thirtieth of July, the provincials wishing them success, and heartily rejoicing that they were gone. 

The fleet consisted of nine ships of war and two bomb-ketches, with about sixty transports, store-ships, hospital-ships, and other vessels, British and provincial.  They carried the seven British regiments, numbering, with the artillery train, about fifty-five hundred men, besides six hundred marines and fifteen hundred provincials; counting, with the sailors, nearly twelve thousand in all. 

Vetch commanded the provincials, having been brought from Annapolis for that purpose.  The great need was of pilots.  Every sailor in New England who had seen the Saint  Lawrence had been pressed into the service, though each and all declared themselves incapable of conducting the fleet to Quebec.  Several had no better knowledge of the river than they had picked up when serving as soldiers under Phips twenty-one years before.  The best among them was the veteran Captain Bonner, who afterwards amused his old age by making a plan of Boston, greatly prized by connoisseurs in such matters.  Vetch had studied the Saint  Lawrence in his several visits to Quebec, but, like Bonner, he had gone up the river only in sloops or other small craft, and was, moreover, no sailor.  One of Walker's ships, the "Chester," sent in advance to cruise in the Gulf, had captured a French vessel commanded by one Paradis, an experienced old voyager, who knew the river well.  He took a bribe of five hundred pistoles to act as pilot; but the fleet would perhaps have fared better if he had refused the money.  He gave such dismal accounts of the Canadian winter that the Admiral could see nothing but ruin ahead, even if he should safely reach his destination.  His tribulation is recorded in his Journal.  "That which now chiefly took up my thoughts, was contriving how to secure the ships if we got up to Quebec; for the ice in the river freezing to the bottom would have utterly destroyed and bilged them as much as if they had been squeezed between rocks. " These misgivings may serve to give the measure of his professional judgment.  Afterwards, reflecting on the situation, he sees cause for gratitude in his own mishaps; "because, had we arrived safe at Quebec, our provisions would have been reduced to a very small proportion, not exceeding eight or nine weeks at short allowance, so that between ten and twelve thousand men must have been left to perish with the extremity of cold and hunger.  I must confess the melancholy contemplation of this (had it happened) strikes me with horror; for how dismal must it have been to have beheld the seas and earth locked up by adamantine frosts, and swoln with high mountains of snow, in a barren and uncultivated region; great numbers of brave men famishing with hunger, and drawing lots who should die first to feed the rest. "

All went well till the eighteenth of August, when there was a strong head-wind, and the ships ran into the Bay of Gaspé.  Two days after, the wind shifted to the southeast, and they set sail again, Walker in his flagship, the "Edgar," being at or near the head of the fleet.  On the evening of the twenty-second they were at some distance above the great Island of Anticosti.  The river is here about seventy miles wide, and no land had been seen since noon of the day before.  There was a strong east wind, with fog.  Walker thought that he was not far from the south shore, when in fact he was at least fifty miles from it, and more than half that distance north of his true course.  At eight in the evening the Admiral signalled the fleet to bring to, under mizzen and main-topsails, with heads turned southward.  At half-past ten, Paddon, the captain of the "Edgar," came to tell him that he saw land which he supposed must be the south shore; on which Walker, in a fatal moment, signalled for the ships to wear and bring to, with heads northward.  He then turned into his berth, and was falling asleep, when a military officer, Captain Goddard, of Seymour's regiment, hastily entered, and begged him to come on deck, saying that there were breakers on all sides.  Walker, scornful of a landsman, and annoyed at being disturbed, answered impatiently and would not stir.  Soon after, Goddard appeared again, and implored him for Heaven's sake to come up and see for himself, or all would be lost.  At the same time the Admiral heard a great noise and trampling, on which he turned out of his berth, put on his dressing-gown and slippers, and going in this attire on deck, found a scene of fright and confusion.  At first he could see nothing, and shouted to the men to reassure them; but just then the fog opened, the moon shone out, and the breaking surf was plainly visible to leeward.  The French pilot, who at first could not be found, now appeared on deck, and declared, to the astonishment of both the Admiral and Captain Paddon, that they were off the north shore.  Paddon, in his perplexity, had ordered an anchor to be let go; Walker directed the cable to be cut, and, making all sail, succeeded in beating to windward and gaining an offing. 

The ship that carried Colonel King, of the artillery, had a narrow escape.  King says that she anchored in a driving rain, "with a shoal of rocks on each quarter within a cable's length of us, which we plainly perceived by the waves breaking over them in a very violent manner. " They were saved by a lull in the gale; for if it had continued with the same violence, he pursues, "our anchors could not have held, and the wind and the vast seas which ran, would have broke our ship into ten thousand pieces against the rocks.  All night we heard nothing but ships firing and showing lights, as in the utmost distress. "

Vetch, who was on board the little frigate "Despatch," says that he was extremely uneasy at the course taken by Walker on the night of the storm.  "I told Colonel Dudley and Captain Perkins, commander of the 'Despatch,' that I wondered what the Flag meant by that course, and why he did not steer west and west-by-south. " The "Despatch" kept well astern, and so escaped the danger.  Vetch heard through the fog guns firing signals of distress; but three days passed before he knew how serious the disaster was.  The ships of war had all escaped; but eight British transports, one store-ship, and one sutler's sloop were dashed to pieces.  "It was lamentable to hear the shrieks of the sinking, drowning, departing souls," writes the New England commissary, Sheaf, who was very near sharing their fate. 

The disaster took place at and near a rocky island, with adjacent reefs, lying off the north shore and called Isle aux Œufs.  On the second day after it happened, Walker was told by the master of one of the wrecked transports that eight hundred and eighty-four soldiers had been lost, and he gives this hasty estimate in his published Journal; though he says in his Introduction to it that the total loss of officers, soldiers, and sailors was scarcely nine hundred.  According to a later and more trustworthy statement, the loss of the troops was twenty-nine officers, six hundred and seventy-six sergeants, corporals, drummers, and private soldiers, and thirty-five women attached to the regiments; that is, a total of seven hundred and forty lives.  The loss of the sailors is not given; but it could scarcely have exceeded two hundred. 

The fleet spent the next two days in standing to and fro between the northern and southern shores, with the exception of some of the smaller vessels employed in bringing off the survivors from the rocks of Isle aux Œufs.  The number thus saved was, according to Walker, four hundred and ninety-nine.  On the twenty-fifth he went on board the General's ship, the "Windsor," and Hill and he resolved to call a council of war.  In fact, Hill had already got his colonels together.  Signals were made for the captains of the men-of-war to join them, and the council began. 

"Jack Hill," the man about town, placed in high command by the influence of his sister, the Queen's tire-woman, had now an opportunity to justify his appointment and prove his mettle.  Many a man of pleasure and fashion, when put to the proof, has revealed the latent hero within him; but Hill was not one of them.  Both he and Walker seemed to look for nothing but a pretext for retreat; and when manhood is conspicuously wanting in the leaders, a council of war is rarely disposed to supply it.  The pilots were called in and examined, and they all declared themselves imperfectly acquainted with the Saint  Lawrence, which, as some of the captains observed, they had done from the first.  Sir William Phips, with pilots still more ignorant, had safely carried his fleet to Quebec in 1690, as Walker must have known, for he had with him Phips's Journal of the voyage.  The expedition had lost about a twelfth part of its soldiers and sailors, besides the transports that carried them; with this exception there was no reason for retreat which might not as well have been put forward when the fleet left Boston.  All the war-ships were safe, and the loss of men was not greater than might have happened in a single battle.  Hill says that Vetch, when asked if he would pilot the fleet to Quebec, refused to undertake it; but Vetch himself gives his answer as follows: "I told him (the Admiral) I never was bred to sea, nor was it any part of my province; but I would do my best by going ahead and showing them where the difficulty of the river was, which I knew pretty well. " The naval captains, however, resolved that by reason of the ignorance of the pilots and the dangerous currents it was impossible to go up to Quebec.  So discreditable a backing out from a great enterprise will hardly be found elsewhere in English annals.  On the next day Vetch, disappointed and indignant, gave his mind freely to the Admiral.  "The late disaster cannot, in my humble opinion, be anyways imputed to the difficulty of the navigation, but to the wrong course we steered, which most unavoidably carried us upon the north shore.  Who directed that course you best know; and as our return without any further attempt would be a vast reflection upon the conduct of this affair, so it would be of very fatal consequence to the interest of the Crown and all the British colonies upon this continent. " His protest was fruitless.  The fleet retraced its course to the gulf, and then steered for Spanish River,—now the harbor of Sydney,—in the Island of Cape Breton; the Admiral consoling himself with the reflection that the wreck was a blessing in disguise and a merciful intervention of Providence to save the expedition from the freezing, starvation, and cannibalism which his imagination had conjured up. 

The frigate "Sapphire" was sent to Boston with news of the wreck and the retreat, which was at once despatched to Nicholson, who, if he continued his movement on Montreal, would now be left to conquer Canada alone.  His force consisted of about twenty-three hundred men, white and red, and when the fatal news reached him he was encamped on Wood Creek, ready to pass Lake Champlain.  Captain Butler, a New York officer at the camp, afterwards told Kalm, the Swedish naturalist, that when Nicholson heard what had happened, he was beside himself with rage, tore off his wig, threw it on the ground and stamped upon it, crying out, "Roguery! Treachery!" When his fit was over, he did all that was now left for him to do,—burned the wooden forts he had built, marched back to Albany, and disbanded his army, after leaving one hundred and fifty men to protect the frontier against scalping-parties. 

Canada had been warned of the storm gathering against her.  Early in August, Vaudreuil received letters from Costebelle, at Placentia, telling him that English prisoners had reported mighty preparations at Boston against Quebec, and that Montreal was also to be attacked.  The colony was ill prepared for the emergency, but no effort was spared to give the enemy a warm reception.  The militia were mustered, Indians called together, troops held in readiness, and defences strengthened.  The saints were invoked, and the aid of Heaven was implored by masses, processions, and penances, as in New England by a dismal succession of fasts.  Mother Juchereau de Saint-Denis tells us how devout Canadians prayed for help from God and the most holy Virgin; "since their glory was involved, seeing that the true religion would quickly perish if the English should prevail. " The general alarm produced effects which, though transient, were thought highly commendable while they lasted.  The ladies, according to Mother Juchereau, gave up their ornaments, and became more modest and more pious.  "Those of Montreal," pursues the worthy nun, "even outdid those of Quebec; for they bound themselves by oath to wear neither ribbons nor lace, to keep their throats covered, and to observe various holy practices for the space of a year. " The recluse of Montreal, Mademoiselle Le Ber, who, by reason of her morbid seclusion and ascetic life, was accounted almost a saint, made a flag embroidered with a prayer to the Virgin, to be borne against the heretical bands of Nicholson. 

When that commander withdrew, his retreat, though not the cause of it, was quickly known at Montreal, and the forces gathered there went down to Quebec to aid in repelling the more formidable attack by sea.  Here all was suspense and expectancy till the middle of October, when the report came that two large ships had been seen in the river below.  There was great excitement, for they were supposed to be the van of the British fleet; but alarm was soon turned to joy by the arrival of the ships, which proved to be French.  On the nineteenth, the Sieur de la Valterie, who had come from Labrador in September, and had been sent down the river again by Vaudreuil to watch for the English fleet, appeared at Quebec with tidings of joy.  He had descended the Saint  Lawrence in a canoe, with two Frenchmen and an Indian, till, landing at Isle aux Œufs on the first of October, they met two French sailors or fishermen loaded with plunder, and presently discovered the wrecks of seven English ships, with, as they declared, fifteen or sixteen hundred dead bodies on the strand hard by, besides dead horses, sheep, dogs, and hens, three or four hundred large iron-hooped casks, a barrel of wine and a barrel and a keg of brandy, cables, anchors, chains, planks, boards, shovels, picks, mattocks, and piles of old iron three feet high. 

"The least devout," writes Mother Juchereau, "were touched by the grandeur of the miracle wrought in our behalf,—a marvellous effect of God's love for Canada, which, of all these countries, is the only one that professes the true religion. "

Quebec was not ungrateful.  A solemn mass was ordered every month during a year, to be followed by the song of Moses after the destruction of Pharaoh and his host.  Amazing reports were spread concerning the losses of the English.  About three thousand of "these wretches"—so the story ran—died after reaching land, without counting the multitudes drowned in the attempt; and even this did not satisfy divine justice, for God blew up one of the ships by lightning during the storm.  Vessels were sent to gather up the spoils of the wreck, and they came back, it was reported, laden with marvellous treasures, including rich clothing, magnificent saddles, plate, silver-hilted swords, and the like; bringing also the gratifying announcement that though the autumn tides had swept away many corpses, more than two thousand still lay on the rocks, naked and in attitudes of despair.  These stories, repeated by later writers, find believers to this day. 

When Walker and his ships reached Spanish River, he called another council of war.  The question was whether, having failed to take Quebec, they should try to take Placentia; and it was resolved that the short supply of provisions, the impossibility of getting more from Boston before the first of November, and the risks of the autumnal storms, made the attempt impracticable.  Accordingly, the New England transports sailed homeward, and the British fleet steered for the Thames. 

Swift writes on the sixth of October in his Journal to Stella: "The news of Mr.  Hill's miscarriage in his expedition came to-day, and I went to visit Mrs.  Masham and Mrs.  Hill, his two sisters, to condole with them. " A week after, he mentions the arrival of the general himself; and again on the sixteenth writes thus: "I was to see Jack Hill this morning, who made that unfortunate expedition; and there is still more misfortune, for that ship which was admiral of his fleet (the "Edgar") is blown up in the Thames by an accident and carelessness of some rogue, who was going, as they think, to steal some gunpowder: five hundred men are lost. "

A report of this crowning disaster reached Quebec, and Mother Juchereau does not fail to improve it.  According to her, the Admiral, stricken with divine justice, and wrought to desperation, blew up the ship himself, and perished with all on board, except only two men. 

There was talk of an examination into the causes of the failure, but nothing was done.  Hill, strong in the influence of Mrs.  Masham, reaped new honors and offices.  Walker, more answerable for the result, and less fortunate in court influence, was removed from command, and his name was stricken from the half-pay list.  He did not, however, blow himself up, but left England and emigrated to South Carolina, whence, thinking himself ill-treated by the authorities, he removed to Barbadoes, and died some years later.